Hi Jenna 💕
Unfortunately, it sounds like this didn't meet your expectations – especially that the color is falling under your eyes during the day, which must be frustrating 😞 While the product has a flake-free formula and an innovative brush for adding volume and length, not all lash types always react to the product the same way.
We appreciate your honest review as it helps other customers get a realistic understanding of this mascara. 💛 If you'd like, we can suggest better alternatives that are known to be long-lasting and less flaky – just let us know what kind of result you're looking for!