Incredible pencil and the color stays like a ROCK!! I've been using NYX Lift and Snatch since it came out and love it, but the color can easily smudge during the day. This pencil I really have to scrub off, you can easily bathe with it and it stays!! So I will definitely buy this again. The only reason it doesn't get full marks is that the tip gets a bit dry and crumbly, and the color isn't super pigmented so you have to shake the pencil and apply a few times to get product out, but otherwise a great product, especially for the price!