In comparison to Nyx eyeliner, which is the best eyeliner in my opinion, this one holds much better. However, it is harder to apply as it almost has a slightly rubbery consistency.
Used it for several years. This one stays put like a rock all day. The tip is also very thin, which makes it incredibly easy to work with in the inner corner of the eye, leading to perfect, even results. Highly recommend!
I've been using this in the color Bleach for about 1 year now and it's really good, creamy, easy to use, good pigment, and lasts a LONG time.
However, I just bought the color Graphite to use as a base for black eyeshadow, and unfortunately, it's almost the opposite, very patchy, drier, and doesn't last nearly as long. They now have a different look on the packaging, so I'm wondering if the formula has also changed or if it's dependent on the color. A bit disappointing since the other one was so good.