Gave these a weak 3 - They look nice, but unfortunately hold very poorly with nail tape. I've been using nails from Switch Nails for a while and they last a MINIMUM of 3 weeks with nail tape, while these fell off before a week was up. Mildly disappointed with the durability. Maybe better with glue... You also have to be careful with the application as air bubbles become clearly visible. As mentioned, they were pretty and the right length, so I will probably buy again and try them with the tape from Switch Nails.