I have to say that this one is really good! Such a good tubing mascara for a very good price!
It delivers what a tubing mascara should:
It stays on all day without settling under the eye or on the eyelid.
It doesn't flake (some flaking at the end of the day occurs, but nothing that is a problem for me).
It washes off with water and falls off in strips/pieces (it doesn't "fall" off in strips quite as easily as, for example, Idun Minerals Vatn tubing/38° mascara, it becomes a bit more crumbly, and you have to work with a bit more water, but water is enough, no makeup remover needed).
It's easy to apply, gives long lashes, and for being a tubing mascara, it gives good volume. But like most other tubing mascaras, it can get a bit clumpy if you try to build up multiple layers. However, it doesn't dry too quickly, so you have time to build a bit on the first layer without it sticking together right away (which can be a bit tricky with Idun Minerals Vatn 38° mascara since it dries very fast when you apply it).
When it comes to the rubber brush, I think it's just the right size and easy to work with.
The only downside for me is that the mascara can weigh down the lashes a bit, and you might not quite get the curl in the lashes that you might wish for.
But the many advantages of this mascara outweigh for me, so I will definitely continue to buy it.
Recommend! 😊