Honestly came for the pretty packaging, but stayed for the product! I liked it a lot- brush is big and fluffy, which gave me a lot of volume and id say some length! The mascara itself is creamy, not too runny like many other ones when they’re new. Its not waterproof (im nor sure if it says it is or not), but its stays on well. It doesnt flake off under my eyes, it does transfer on my upper lid throughout the day, which even waterproof ones do because i have oily lids, but this one doesnt smudge a lot i notice, just a little bit. The only obvious con im a bit sad about - this mascara doesnt hold the curl.. my eyelashes are very straight, so i curls them quite heavily, but as soon as i put this mascara on they drop straight away. I can look past it tho since it makes my lashes so viaible and big.