I've tried many black eyeliners but this one is unbeatable for me. Stays like a ROCK and doesn't crumble or smudge all day, holds up even at night after some touch-ups. Very easy to apply as well. Very grateful, buying again and again!

I liked the product, but it disappears by itself from the container! I've checked that it hasn't leaked into my bag or that the cap was properly closed, but that's not the reason. It just disappears by itself, especially after storage in the bag, a significant amount of the product has gone missing. It was good, but it went to waste. I managed to use it a few times.☹️

I like it! Nice color and not as dry on the lips as my other lipsticks. You can twist the lipstick up from the bottom of the pencil, which is very nice. However, I still need to use a bit of lip balm underneath, and since it said serum in the name, I expected it to be a bit more moisturizing. I also feel like the cap easily falls off in my bag, and it has smeared a few times. Overall, though, a very good product!