e.l.f.Lash XTNDR Mascara Deep Brown

Reviews & comments

Review product

Headline*!

Publish

• Most helpful positive

  Cindy J

  1 month

  Good but not the best 🥱

  ✨ First impression Big and nice brush, was easy to apply and didn’t smudge. Gave a very nice, quite natural result with really long and beautiful lashes. Big plus for being super easy to wash off! I always do double cleansing, but the mascara was completely gone after the first step without any major effort 🥹🤌🏻 🧁 About me I have long lashes myself and quite curled, but a bit sparse. I usually prefer mascaras that give volume over length. Usually don’t need more than two coats to be satisfied with the result. 🇸🇪 My thoughts and experiences I initially liked the big brush, but it’s almost on the verge of being a bit too big actually. There’s a smudge risk when the brushes are too long, and I’ve accidentally smudged a couple of times when using this mascara, and that’s not common for me 🥲 But I appreciate that it’s easy to use, the product distributes well on the brush, and the mascara doesn’t clump. 🏁 Summary ➕ 🎉 Super easy to wash off 😍🤌🏻 🎉 Really gives long lashes as promised 🎉 Affordable ➖ 🧐 A bit too long brush, can easily get messy I wavered between rating 3 and 4, it probably won’t be a repurchase for me, but I still think you get a good mascara for the price, so I round up to 4! 🥶🤩 ✨💖 4/5 💖✨ #lykoinflutester #elf

  

  +1

  1 product in post Good but not the best 🥱
  12 likes

  1 comment

  1160 views

  Anna
  1 month
  Such a beautiful result 😍!

  Log in to leave a comment
• Most helpful negative

  Eliza

  1 month

  Verifierad testare

  👁️ Clumsy of me 👁️

  #ELFCosmetics has arrived!!! 😱 I've probably heard a lot of fantastic things through American influencers, so I was happily surprised that my #LykoInflutester package contained FOUR products to test now that they finally have their premiere on #Lyko!!! 🤩 A simple tube that somehow looks a bit cheap, in my opinion.. 🙈 The brush has a firm but soft bristle with separated spikes. The product is fragrance-free, and unfortunately felt a bit dry, or dries quickly, might be the problem - I just can't apply quickly enough before it starts to clump and lay unevenly. 😔 Sometimes it goes very smoothly, though, so it depends a bit on my speed that day. 😅 The

  

  

  +2

  1 product in post 👁️ Clumsy of me 👁️
  13 likes

  2 comments

  831 views

  Show older (1 more)

  Eliza
  1 month
  Ida Yes, unfortunately not, have to get faster at my makeup But super fun to finally get to try this brand and try something new! 🥰
  Like

  Log in to leave a comment
• Irma Maria Birgitta

  1 month

  Bad

  It creates small clumps in the lashes with this mascara. I really wanted to like it.😞

  1 product in post Bad
  Like

  1 comment

  215 views

  Emelie
  Customer service at Lyko
  1 month
  Hey there Oh, how unfortunate that this didn't become a new favorite as hoped. Keeping my fingers crossed that you find the one that suits you soon 🤞💖
  Like

  Log in to leave a comment
• GABRIELLA

  1 month

  Verifierad testare

  Natural

  I think the e.l.f. Lash XTNDR Mascara in Pitch Black is a pretty okay mascara. It gives my lashes an intense black color and lifts them so they look longer and fuller. The formula feels light and doesn't clump, which makes the lashes look natural even though you can apply it multiple times for a dramatic effect. The brush is designed to catch all the lashes, even the smallest ones, so the result is even and nice. The only downside is that it's not waterproof, so it can smudge a bit on humid days. But for daily use and at such a good price, I would definitely recommend it. A budget-friendly mascara that delivers far beyond expectations🤩🙌🏽 #LYKOINFLUTESTER #ELF

  

  

  1 product in post Natural
  8 likes

  Comment

  756 views
• Evelina

  1 month

  Verifierad testare

  Amazing result ✨

  Do you want a mascara that really makes your lashes pop with volume, strength, and length? This one is for you! I naturally have pretty long lashes, maybe just above "medium length", but this mascara still gives me a wow feeling! It's extremely easy to work with; I apply 1 layer and then just enhance where needed with an extra layer, but I curl the lashes first! It does weigh the lashes down a bit after curling them, at least when you apply mascara all the way to the root. This is, however, completely unavoidable when it’s not waterproof, of course. It really doesn’t smudge, which you can see on the brush that it looks completely clean. Any mess that might occur at the lash line comes off sooooo easily with a cotton swab afterward. Plus, it washes off so easily? I don’t understand how that’s possible, but it just glides off without rubbing 🤖🏽 Also, it should be added that it stays put like a charm hour in and hour out throughout the day! Pretty okay sweat-resistant; I, who work with training and sweat a lot (hello HIIT classes), think it’s more than acceptable after a workout since it doesn’t run off, but it does leave a few smudges around the eyes. As proof, I’m including a picture taken a minute after a Sprint + Bodyattack class (sweat fest) where I’m wearing this mascara!! No, but this result for the price, no, it can’t be anything less than 5 out of 5, run and buy it already!! #elf #lykoinflutester

  

  

  +2

  1 product in post Amazing result ✨
  7 likes

  Comment

  487 views
• Isabella

  1 month

  Verifierad testare

  Gives really nice length to the lashes

  As a #lykoinflutester, I got to try e.l.f. Lash XTNDR Mascara Pitch Black. If we start with the outside of the product. I think it had a nice packaging, maybe a bit unnecessary to also have a cardboard box when it really didn't serve a greater purpose. But the inside, you guys! Oh, I am so in love with this mascara. It has become a part of my daily routine and makeup. My lashes get long and have a nice intense black without feeling clumpy. It also stays on really well, no risk of mascara falling under the eyes. Something I would have wished for, which is what brings the rating down a bit, is that I would have liked it to separate the lashes more. Otherwise, a really great mascara that is very affordable! Highly recommend! #elf

  

  

  +4

  1 product in post Gives really nice length to the lashes
  6 likes

  Comment

  504 views
• Wilma

  1 month

  Not so impressed

  Nja, this mascara was not a hit for me. The mascara doesn't clump and is easy to apply, but it doesn't give any wow feeling either in terms of volume or darkness on the lashes. After a few hours of use, it also starts to flake, and there are black dots under the eyes. The positive is that I like the hard brush that separates the lashes nicely, and if you're not looking for a huge effect, this can work as a nice everyday mascara with a relatively natural result. It also gives, as promised, quite a bit of length to the lashes. However, I use eyelash serum regularly and naturally have relatively long lashes. However, the rating is mostly brought down by the fact that my eyes seemed to be a bit sensitive to this. The morning after wearing the mascara, and of course having washed it off when I went to bed, I woke up with gunk and grit in my eyes. It's as if it makes my eyes drier. I haven't experienced this with any other mascara and don't think I have particularly sensitive eyes otherwise. So unfortunately, it will be a low rating from me! The pictures show no mascara but bent lashes, as well as with the mascara. LYKOINFLUTESTER & #ELF

  

  

  1 product in post Not so impressed
  3 likes

  Comment

  410 views
• Johanna

  1 month

  Verifierad testare

  Unfortunately not for me..

  I've been able to test this mascara for a while now, and even though I usually love products from Elf, this one was not a hit for me 🤷‍♀️ The mascara has a nice black color, but I find it hard to get product on the brush. Maybe I got a Monday model? Since it’s not waterproof, it unfortunately smudges under my eyes, and for that reason, I prefer and only use waterproof mascaras. However, this is not unique to this mascara, but all mascaras I’ve ever tested, except for the waterproof ones, smudge under my eyes. How was the length then? I always curl my lashes before applying mascara, BUT they quickly fall back to their natural “shape” and length, unless I use waterproof mascara. So here, it was unfortunately a bit of a disappointment. Aside from what has been less good about the mascara, I really like the brush! It’s easy to reach and I like that it’s quite slim, meaning it’s not so “fluffy” and soft like some can be. Also, the black color is very nice! 🥰 Otherwise, the mascara felt comfortable on the lashes and didn’t cause any irritation or itching. I can imagine that the mascara could be great for someone else who doesn’t have the same problems as I do. For me, it has always been hard to find good mascaras! Unfortunately, I can’t take a picture now of the result of the lashes since I’ve done a lash lift and should avoid mascara on these, but I’m attaching some other pictures instead 🥰 #LYKOINFLUTESTER #ELF

  

  

  +1

  1 product in post Unfortunately not for me..
  7 likes

  Comment

  447 views
• Louise

  1 month

  Verifierad testare

  Great mascara for the price! 💖

  This mascara is for those of us who want length on our lashes. At first, I had trouble getting the mascara evenly distributed on my lashes, which resulted in spider legs. After a few tries, the result got better. It says the mascara is clump-free, but I don't think so, as it really comes down to finding a way to avoid clumps. I've found that way now, but for me, it should be quick with mascara; I shouldn't have to fiddle 😅 It also says the brush is flexible, which made me think of my favorite mascara, L'Oréal's telescopic, and that Elf's mascara could be a cheaper alternative to it, but I find the brush hard! Maybe a bit too stiff. That's why I give it 3 ✨✨✨. The mascara lasts all day for me, is easy to remove, and doesn't flake at all, even though I've worked out with it on, been in the wind, worked long days, etc., so it's really good for the price, but I do think it promises a little too much 🤖🏽 #lykoinflutester #elf

  

  1 product in post Great mascara for the price! 💖
  11 likes

  Comment

  481 views
• ALICIA WALL

  1 month

  Verifierad testare

  BEFORE & AFTER

  Mascara This really gives such a nice effect! I get both volume and length, and it didn't take much product to get results. It also worked really well for layering, which is a big plus for those times I want to feel a bit more “done up” ✅ Good price ✅ Love the brush ✅ Gives volume ✅ Gives a lot of color ✅ Gives length Super nice product! #LYKOINFLUTESTER #ELF

  

  

  +1

  1 product in post BEFORE & AFTER
  4 likes

  Comment

  399 views
• Beatrice

  1 month

  Verifierad testare

  Luxury at a cheap price

  How can this not cost more? 😍 The result is like luxury mascara. The silicone brush really catches every little eyelash and makes the lashes look both longer and fuller! Best of all - it doesn't flake under the eye! And it's easy to wash off. I didn't curl my lashes beforehand and didn't feel like I needed to. I got a nice natural lift from the mascara. New mascaras tend to be a bit tricky, I think, since so much wet product comes on the brush, so I usually like them best after 2-3 weeks 😅 but this one felt good from the start! No excess or mess. The result is separated long lashes that definitely have a lengthening effect! In the picture, you can see one eye with mascara and the other without. Such a big difference! 👁️ I don't understand why the products don't cost more 😢🤦‍♀️ It doesn't feel like budget makeup at all! #elf #lykoinflutester

  

  

  1 product in post Luxury at a cheap price
  4 likes

  Comment

  369 views
• Frida

  1 month

  Verifierad testare

  VALUE FOR MONEY

  I didn't have high expectations for this mascara, but it delivered! 😃 I usually use mascaras that are in the price range of 300-400 kr, which is why I didn't have such high expectations for the e.l.f mascara. But I was pleasantly surprised! I love when the brush is made of rubber like this one, it makes the lashes separate nicely. The mascara was easy to work with and gave nice length. It didn't flake during the day and stayed nice all the way until the evening. My lashes usually fall down during the day, so I always curl my lashes and apply a thin layer of waterproof mascara. This keeps the lashes curled and nice all day, then I always apply another two layers of regular mascara for the best result. This mascara will definitely continue to be used. #lykoinflutester #elf

  

  +1

  1 product in post VALUE FOR MONEY
  10 likes

  2 comments

  805 views

  Show older (1 more)

  Aka
  1 month
  Lovely you🌸💕
  Like

  Log in to leave a comment